← All insights
The Novel Shift

The mob we built: how the R&D sector marketed itself into crisis

This article looked into a single, nagging question: in a sector damaged by aggressive marketing, how do you sell your services without adding to the noise?

Sanela Tomlinson
·
July 9, 2025
·
Last updated
·
7 min read
The mob we built: how the R&D sector marketed itself into crisis

My recent conversation with Rufus Meakin was driven by a single, nagging question: in a sector damaged by aggressive marketing, how do you sell your services without adding to the noise? As someone responsible for marketing and designing Novel, this topic created a familiar tension.

Given that Rufus has successfully established a powerful presence on LinkedIn, I asked him to share his thoughts on what it takes to build a credible presence on the platform today. We discussed the industry’s ‘gold rush’ crisis, the power of opinion, and the nuances of marketing R&D tax relief services. This blog post summarises the lessons from our conversation, enriched by your comments, and offers a guide for advisors looking to use LinkedIn to scale their business.

The Anatomy of the Crisis

I always found it fascinating how the tide of public opinion can turn with breathtaking speed. One minute, a brand is a cultural staple; the next, it’s the villain of a global drama, engulfed by a digital mob. Classic tales of marketing mishaps, like the Pepsi, Bud Light, and Jaguar campaigns, show what happens when a company misreads the room and the consumer mob delivers a swift, brutal verdict.

But what happens when the people marketing the product or service are the very ones who tainted its reputation? This is the curious case of the UK’s R&D tax relief sector. A story not of one catastrophic ad campaign, but of a thousand tiny cuts inflicted from the inside. The damage wasn’t caused by a backlash from clients, but a divide between agents and what seemed appropriate when selling R&D services.

This wasn’t a sudden storm. It was a slow, creeping rot. According to Rufus, one of the most prominent voices chronicling our industry's challenges, the problems began as early as 2015. As he tells it, the market became saturated. High-quality, established advisors had their client base. New, low-quality entrants realised the only way to win business was to venture into untapped markets. The problem? These "untapped markets" were often companies that weren't actually performing eligible R&D.

“They could win by taking business from competitors, but because those competitors were actually better, with better services, they had to go into untapped markets to companies that weren’t really doing R&D,” Rufus explained. This created a dangerous race to the bottom, fuelled by aggressive and often misleading marketing. Realising that this cannot go on forever, Rufus turned to the LinkedIn newsletter to try to raise awareness about this situation.

The Marketing Conundrum: How Do You Sell a Service Prone to Abuse?

Marketing R&D tax relief services is not easy. “R&D tax relief marketing is really hard because there are so many things you can’t say… You can’t make big statements about how great you are, how much money you can get, how successful you’ve been,” said Rufus.

This is the tightrope that legitimate advisors must walk: say just enough to be correct without turning it into an essay project. Meanwhile, the architects of the industry's ‘gold rush’ charged ahead with reckless abandonment, willingly sharing misinformation.

However, when it comes to advisors sharing misinformation within our industry, I categorise them into two camps. I would categorise a reckless advisor as one who willingly shares misinformation. For example, if the marketing sounded something like this: 'creating a new pub menu is innovative and eligible for R&D tax relief,' then welcome to camp 1.

Alternatively, if the advisor had one of our favourite phrases to nitpick as a community, 'we have a 100% success rate' on their website, I would consider them a victim of herd mentality and in camp 2. Why victim? Well, when everyone else has this phrase on their website, not having it also may counterintuitively come across as your business being less successful. Herd mentality is rarely logical.

The next rational question to ask is, well, why put it on the website if you know it's incorrect? One could argue that out of all the misinformation about R&D tax relief, is this that harmful? It's not like we're saying that turning a sausage roll into a sausage sandwich is innovative. But sadly, in the world of tax, this sort of thinking gets you in trouble.

Graham Webber noted that in tax, you're selling an "opinion" to an audience that is often "ill-informed" and has "no wish to be better informed". This highlights another problem: the audience wants to believe in the fairytale, which is why so many companies fall victim to rogue advisors.

Even advice geared towards radical simplicity, like the "Ronseal approach" suggested by Antony Monger, where we should "do what it says on the tin". On the surface, it's perfect advice: be direct and clear. But when it comes to R&D tax relief, what's "on the tin" is inherently subjective. If the rules were black and white, we wouldn't have a constant stream of tribunals dedicated to interpreting the legislation. This subjectivity is the very reason the "fairytale" narrative is so tempting and dangerous.

This is why people like Rufus continually advocate for us to monitor and be vigilant of how we market our services so we can adhere to good standards as a community.

The Path Forward

The duality of the situation, where, on the one hand, you have people selling the fairytale vs the messy reality, exposes the fundamental weakness of traditional marketing in the R&D sector. A 100-character ad, a flashy banner, or a snappy slogan cannot convey the nuance required.

So, if loud promises are out and nuanced truths, such as a “80-90% success rate but don’t worry, we just got sick of replying to HMRC’s 100 inexperienced emails,” are hard to market, where do we go?

This is precisely where the power of a platform like the LinkedIn newsletter emerges as the clear solution. Unlike a restrictive ad, its long-form nature provides the necessary space to unpack complex opinions and educate an audience, shifting the goal from simple advertising to building genuine credibility.

Crucially, it also becomes a powerful new form of social proof. Instead of making claims on a corporate website with no oversight, your expertise is shown publicly. The resulting engagement is a live, verifiable endorsement of your authority, arguably more potent than any static testimonial.

When it came to utilising LinkedIn newsletter, Rufus has one fundamental rule, which is “you have to have an opinion. If you haven’t got an opinion, nobody wants to read it.” His newsletter, the R&D Tax Credit Insider, became a must-read, not because it simply reported news, but because it provided deep, opinion-led analysis.

After The Gold Rush, Reputation is Everything

Unlike with the marketing mistakes of big companies mentioned earlier, the force that turned the tide in the R&D sector wasn't the public; it was the rogue agents whose marketing promises were so loud and outrageous that they forced a regulatory crackdown, tarnishing the reputation of everyone. Where Pepsi could pull an ad and apologise, the damage in the R&D world was systemic, with lasting economic consequences.

The story of the R&D tax relief sector is a powerful, if painful, case study. It shows that a marketing mishap doesn't always have to be a single, explosive event. It can be a slow, corrosive campaign waged by a sector against itself. The path back, as demonstrated by voices like Rufus, isn't through louder slogans or flashier campaigns. It's by speaking openly, challenging the consensus and building a reputation of expertise.

‍

The Novel Shift

Enjoyed this issue? Get the next one on LinkedIn.

Subscribe on LinkedIn
Book a walkthrough

See how Novel fits the way your team already works.

Book a 30-minute walkthrough