I found myself asking the same question I often see advisors asking clients at the start of a new claim: are you really prepared for this?

I found myself asking the same question I often see advisors asking clients at the start of a new claim: are you really prepared for this?
Talking publicly about the future of R&D tax relief is very different from quietly observing the scheme in the background. But in getting under the hood of Novel and its evolving platform, it’s becoming clear how much is changing, not only in the platform itself, but in the behaviour and expectations of advisors, claimants, and HMRC.
This edition explores a trend that’s starting to feel inevitable: the move from retrospective to real-time R&D claim preparation. Is it the future? If so, what will that mean for advisors, their clients, and the increasingly compliance-heavy scheme they’re now navigating?
The term “real-time R&D” might not mean much at first. Historically, R&D tax relief has often been retrospective. My first year preparing R&D claims was a blur of last-minute technical narratives, incomplete cost data, and amended returns filed just hours before the deadline. Back then, this was normal. But now, it feels increasingly unrecognisable.
With the rules tightening – rightly so – HMRC is scrutinising claims more closely than ever. Could this finally signal the end of retrospective claim preparation?
In my opinion, there are two potential forces driving this change:
Let’s start with compliance. The introduction of claim notification form requirements means companies can no longer afford to treat R&D claims as an afterthought. Last year, HMRC introduced a rule requiring companies to notify them within six months of their year-end if they intend to make a claim. Miss the deadline? The claim is lost, unless an exemption applies.
And here’s where it gets tricky, the exemption rules are surprisingly complex. I’ve already seen eligible companies miss out simply because they didn’t realise they needed to notify HMRC in the first place. This isn’t a question of eligibility, it’s a systemic problem that limits when clients can claim, regardless of the work they’ve done. And it’s one that real-time R&D preparation could help solve.
On the enquiry side, HMRC is now requesting more evidence, and in greater detail, than ever before. Defending retroactive claims under these standards is much harder, particularly for teams without solid records of their past R&D activities, making it difficult to accurately demonstrate eligibility.
Sure, preparing a claim after year-end has its advantages: it’s administratively convenient and allows claimants to focus on the process without disrupting current work. But those benefits are fading. Fast.
HMRC is no longer just asking what R&D occurred, they want to know when, why, and who was involved. The intent to claim matters, and so does thorough documentation.
Retrospective claims often struggle with accuracy and robustness because key details get lost over time. Clients forget what they worked on, records go missing, Jira boards get archived, and people leave the business.
And let’s be honest, trying to remember what happened 18 months ago is challenging enough without also trying to align costs and timesheets.
Personally, I suspect that the introduction of the claim notification form wasn’t just about improving compliance, it was also a strategic move to reduce the volume of retrospective claims altogether.
Real-time R&D preparation might sound intimidating, but in practice, it makes life easier.
For claimants, it means keeping better record-keeping, cleaner audit trails, and fewer missed deadlines.
For advisors, it means faster claim preparation, higher accuracy, and improved client transparency.
In short, it’s a win-win that aligns with HMRC’s goals of moving towards intentional, robust submissions.
There’s a phrase I’m sure everyone’s heard before: “We’ll just do it the way we always have.”
But that phrase is quickly becoming a liability.
The new rules are specifically designed to move claims away from last-minute amended returns. And with HMRC’s evolving expectations, if you weren’t thinking about R&D at the time, you probably weren’t doing it, at least, not in their eyes.
As a result, companies filing retrospective claims may be more likely to be challenged, even when the underlying R&D work is eligible. In this environment, staying ahead of administrative and compliance requirements isn’t just best practice, it’s essential.