← All insights
The Novel Shift

More than just numbers: the unexpected creativity of an R&D tax advisor - July Edition

When you picture a tax advisor, the word ‘creative’ probably isn’t the first that springs to mind.

Sanela Tomlinson
·
August 7, 2025
·
Last updated
·
7 min read
More than just numbers: the unexpected creativity of an R&D tax advisor - July Edition

When you picture a tax advisor, the word ‘creative’ probably isn’t the first that springs to mind. Diligent, analytical, meticulous - absolutely. But creative? That label seems reserved for artists and marketers. However, in the nuanced world of R&D tax relief, I’d argue that creativity is a welcome bonus. I wouldn’t go as far as to say that it is essential, but it certainly helps when dealing with clients.

Let's be clear: this isn't about ‘creative accounting’, instead it's about creative communication. It’s about an advisor's ability to translate dense and complex tax legislation into something a client can not only understand but actively engage with.

What got me thinking about this topic was my recent discussion with Mark Rodmell. Although the topic we were discussing was client education, I noted how many analogies he used to clarify various parts of the R&D legislation. This got me thinking, what role does creativity play in all of this? Going a step further, could it foster better compliance amongst claimants?

I realise this topic is a little out there, which could be why I haven’t seen many posts about it. Honestly, I also found it difficult to organise my thoughts, but I wanted to explore this subject and hear your opinions. After all, what’s the purpose of a LinkedIn newsletter if not to discuss such topics?

Compliance: The Unshakeable Foundation

Before we get carried away with the role of creativity, let’s establish a critical baseline. The primary, non-negotiable duty of any good R&D advisor is unwavering commitment to compliance. A great advisor is, first and foremost, a technical expert. They are diligent professionals who understand the legislation inside and out, rigorously vet every project against the BEIS (now DSIT) guidelines, and ensure that every figure is substantiated. They proactively test the robustness of a claim, rather than waiting for HMRC to do so.

This technical rigour forms the essential foundation for everything else. Without it, there is no valid R&D claim - only a potential liability.

The ‘Bonus’ Skill: Where Creativity Comes In

Once compliance is firmly established, an advisor can then enhance their practice through creativity.

There’s an idea often attributed to physicist Richard Feynman: you don't truly understand something until you can explain it simply. For an R&D advisor, this means transforming pages of complex government guidance into clear, straightforward explanations for busy founders, CTOs and other competent professionals. This is where an advisor’s creativity comes into play, the ability to find the right analogy or story to make a complex concept click. This is a valuable skill that isn’t often discussed.

Over the past few months, I’ve examined the crisis in our industry from multiple angles, but it seems that there could be a common thread: the breakdown in the advisor-client relationship.

The Perfect Storm

In one of Paul Rosser’s recent posts, he described a company undergoing a compliance check that had never seen its claim document because their advisor chose not to show it. My initial, somewhat naive reaction was to wonder why a company wouldn’t ask to see it?

Funny enough, that’s something Mark Rodmell called “the curse of hindsight”. He was talking about how clients, once they succeed in a project, tend to forget the problems and uncertainties they experienced at the start. However, in my case, my hindsight made me assume that a technical and financial narrative would always accompany a claim as part of good practice (even before the new legislation required it), unless the claim value was small.

Paul had to point out a stark reality to me that some advisors never told their clients that such documentation was necessary. Adding another perspective, David Maslen noted that you get some clients who are complicit, happy to “look the other way” and “take a punt” on what they suspect were “flaky” claims to get “easy money”.

Could the use of creativity, stories and analogies have prevented this situation? Let’s be honest, no. The agent’s initial goal was flawed. However, an informed client or a client open to learning about the scheme is far less likely to be taken advantage of.

For example, in a well-known story amongst our peers, where ZLX tried to get the Scottish fruit and vegetable wholesaler, James Mackie Wholesale Ltd, to submit an R&D tax relief claim for the installation of a standard refrigerator unit, it was the owner who had the initial good sense to question the validity of such a move. Here's a post by Rufus Meakin that explains it in more detail.

The Cartographer and The Navigator

A client who is simply told "don't worry, you qualify" is a passive recipient. They have no knowledge about the scheme and therefore no ability to discern between what’s right and wrong. But a client who understands why their work qualifies becomes an active participant in the claim preparation process. They are educated, and an educated client is the best defence against a fraudulent claim because they can spot red flags more easily.

This leads me to a new perspective on our profession. I see two main archetypes of a good R&D advisor, both grounded in compliance but differing in their methods. Since Mark’s analogies brought me here, I thought it would be fitting to create an analogy to help describe this.

The Cartographer: The Cartographer is the essential, technically proficient advisor. They know the regulations like a map. They can design and build a claim that is structurally sound, safe, and fully compliant. They are masters of the technical craft, and our industry depends on their diligence. Every good advisor must be a Cartographer.

The Navigator: The Navigator has all the skills of the Cartographer, but with an added layer of creative communication. They don't just build the structure but also use stories and analogies to simplify the process, turning it from a confusing transaction into a collaborative journey. The Navigator builds the same compliant claim but also builds the client's knowledge and confidence along with it.

While the industry needs Cartographers to ensure its integrity, I believe its future health and the restoration of trust depend on cultivating more Navigators. The goal shouldn’t be just to file compliant claims, but to create an ecosystem of informed clients who understand the value and spirit of the R&D scheme. And in an industry so heavily reliant on referrals, this could have a significant compounding effect.

One Point for the Humans

This brings me to my final point. If we accept that a key role of an R&D advisor is this act of creative translation, then tools like automation or R&D tax relief claim preparation software, such as Novel, are not a threat. They are what they’ve always been - a tool.

Can an algorithm deploy the perfect analogy to help a sceptical engineer see the innovation in their work? Can it sense the hesitation in a client's voice and help them understand the risks? The true, lasting value of a human advisor is the "human" element (I know, I hear it too, it sounds cheesy, but I stand by it). It’s the interpersonal relationship built when we go the extra mile to be creative, to find the right words that resonate with our clients and empower them with knowledge.

‍

The Novel Shift

Enjoyed this issue? Get the next one on LinkedIn.

Subscribe on LinkedIn
Book a walkthrough

See how Novel fits the way your team already works.

Book a 30-minute walkthrough