← All insights
The Novel Shift

Bridging the knowledge gap: training accountants in R&D tax relief

Looking at the gap between the technical requirements of the scheme and the support for those advising on it

Belle Chippington
·
October 9, 2025
·
Last updated
·
5 min read
Bridging the knowledge gap: training accountants in R&D tax relief

Novel’s recent partnership with The R&D Community Ltd, a platform specialising in R&D training and support, made me consider the gap between the technical requirements of the scheme and the support for those advising on it.

The past few years have seen the scheme undergo significant changes. Fraud crackdowns, new administrative burdens, and heightened HMRC scrutiny, have left us scrambling to keep up. The R&D scheme has rapidly evolved into a compliance-heavy discipline, requiring deeper technical expertise, detailed evidence of work undertaken, and more time required to submit compliant claims.

In this edition, I explore the challenges accountants face as the R&D scheme grows increasingly complex, who they can turn to for support, and what steps can help bridge the gap between today’s technical demands and the expertise advisors need to succeed.

Why has the R&D tax relief scheme undergone changes in recent years?

I think we can all agree that the uncontrolled level of fraud and error within the scheme had reached unsustainable levels, often driven by unscrupulous advisors submitting claims for sectors such as care homes and restaurants, sectors never intended to qualify. For years, many of these fraudulent claims slipped through with very little resistance, gradually eroding confidence in what activities were genuinely eligible under the scheme.

Today, with the scheme’s shifting focus on compliance, the boundaries of eligibility can feel more blurred than ever. HMRC’s guidance, which is notoriously difficult to interpret, hasn’t made things any clearer. Furthermore, with five schemes currently operating, the associated complexities are greater than ever, requiring advisors to be more thorough and better prepared than before. In my experience, preparing a claim now is significantly more challenging, and it’s likely that fewer claims are being submitted as a result.

Given these challenges, accountants are effectively being left underprepared to navigate R&D claims, often struggling with subjectivity and uncertainty over what truly qualifies. Unless they actively keep up with the evolving requirements and invest in ongoing training, they risk falling behind. In today’s complex landscape, being informed and proactive isn’t just advisable, it’s essential for ensuring claims are compliant.

What role can accountants play in R&D?

A new opportunity is opening up for accountants within the R&D tax relief scheme. Following HMRC’s recent crackdown on fraudulent R&D advisors, infamously highlighted by cases such as Green Jellyfish, many clients are now distancing themselves from unscrupulous consultants. As a result, there is an influx of businesses seeking credible, trusted advisors to help them continue claiming under the scheme. For many companies, accountants are the first port of call.

That said, this opportunity is not without its challenges. While accountants play a vital role in managing company finances, their expertise is typically broad rather than specialised. Their financial knowledge provides valuable insight, ensuring costings are accurate, reliable, and traceable, and that claims are compliant with tax legislation. However, the technical narrative is complex, demanding not just knowledge of tax law but also an understanding of the underlying science and technology.

Without relevant experience in the claimant’s field of technology, accountants often struggle to ask the right questions or to frame technological advances accurately against the industry baseline. This increases the risk of misinterpreting complex legislation, whether by wrongly assuming activities' eligibility or by inadvertently misunderstanding the rules.

When should accountants seek external help?

For accountants without in-house expertise in preparing claims, partnering with trusted external R&D consultants offers a practical solution. In this arrangement, the consultant takes full responsibility for the submission while the accountant retains oversight of the process. For firms with multiple clients potentially eligible for R&D relief, this approach not only streamlines the process, but also enables accountants to retain referral fees. However, it does not necessarily build the accountant’s own technical expertise, since much of the work is outsourced.

An alternative approach is to engage an external consultant in a review capacity rather than fully outsourcing the claim. In this model, the accountant prepares the claim in-house, with the consultant providing independent oversight and technical validation. This not only reassures the accountant that the claim is robust before submission to HMRC but also helps them build their own knowledge of the R&D scheme over time.

What about Novel?

Another avenue worth exploring is the use of specialised software. With the rapid rise of AI technologies, there is growing potential for tools designed specifically to support R&D claim preparation. Emerging platforms are beginning to harness AI trained on DSIT guidelines to review technical narratives, identify risks or gaps, and provide tailored, comprehensive feedback to strengthen submissions. For accountants, these tools can streamline the process and provide added reassurance.

That’s why we built Novel Intelligence. Leveraging SmartClaim's AI capabilities, it takes interview transcripts and turns them into structured technical narratives. Critically, it reviews the draft, highlighting potential inaccuracies or gaps and helping ensure the narrative fully aligns with HMRC’s standards. For new starters, this provides the reassurance they need to boost confidence, for experienced accountants, it’s a major time-saver.

However, AI cannot replace the depth of technical knowledge that comes from in-house expertise or trusted external specialists. By combining financial expertise with technical insights, accountants can act as trusted advisors, delivering real value to clients navigating the R&D scheme.

Whether through training, external support, or cutting-edge technology, streamlining R&D processes isn’t optional, it’s essential to stay ahead. When used responsibly, tools like Novel Intelligence can be a game-changer, saving time, reducing risk, and boosting efficiency, in an increasingly complex R&D landscape.

What’s Next?

In next month’s edition, I’ll continue discussing the use of AI, but this time from a different perspective. Following the recent First-tier Tribunal ruling, should HMRC be using AI to handle R&D tax credit claims? We’ll examine the role of AI in this context and explore what the potential implications could mean for claimant companies.

The Novel Shift

Enjoyed this issue? Get the next one on LinkedIn.

Subscribe on LinkedIn
Book a walkthrough

See how Novel fits the way your team already works.

Book a 30-minute walkthrough